Grubhub,Naked Poison II which describes itself in regulatory filings and marketing copy as the leading platform for restaurant pick-up and delivery orders, is trying its best to convince a courtroom that's not what it is.
In the face of a groundbreaking lawsuit from two former delivery drivers, Grubhub chief operations officer Stan Chia took the stand on Friday to say that actually Grubhub is not a food delivery company; it's "the premiere marketplace connecting diners with restaurants," according to TechCrunch's report.
SEE ALSO: Grubhub buys Yelp's Eat24 to tighten its grip on food deliveryAt issue in the trial is whether or not the two drivers should be considered more protected W-2 employees or independent contractors. Grubhub classified them as the latter, and they claim that was a violation of California employment law.
The point of this particular gambit is to satisfy a state legal precedent called the Borello test, which is used to determine proper employment status in the eyes of the law. Under its criteria, workers who are employed in a company's core business are more likely to be entitled to a more stable and robust job contract.
Thus, Grubhub must make the case that delivering food is not its core business, contrary to what much of its advertising and financial reports say.
It is true that Grubhub only got into the food delivery game in 2015 after a decade as an online ordering platform that only facilitated pickup and deliveries handled by restaurant staff. But it's doubled down on its own delivery operation since then, absorbing other major services like Seamless and Yelp's Eat24 along the way. As of today, it is by far the biggest food delivery service on the market.
A Grubhub spokesperson said in an emailed statement that delivery is a "significant component of the experience" for most of its customers.
"Grubhub works with its restaurant partners in one of two ways. We process orders for restaurants that employ their own delivery staff -- as is the case with a majority of our restaurant partners -- and we offer delivery for restaurants that don't operate their own service in-house," the spokesperson said. "In both cases, delivery is a significant component of the experience; while diners do have the option of picking up their food directly from a restaurant, most diners choose to have their meal delivered."
Chia also argued in court on Friday that most drivers enjoy the flexibility of the independent contractor set-up, to which the plaintiff's lawyer countered that Grubhub is facing another similar lawsuit involving more than 7,000 drivers.
Much is riding on this trial. It's the first time that a California court has tackled the question of whether the legions of loosely employed workers of the so-called "gig economy" should have a right to W-2 employment status, which would make them eligible for benefits like mileage reimbursements and health insurance. The court's decision could have implications for the rest of the on-demand tech industry as well.
While it may sound brazen, Grubhub's case is not the first time this shape-shifting argument has been used in a bid to shield on-demand companies from expensive labor regulation. Uber argued that it's an “information society services provider” rather than a taxi service when confronted with similar charges.
Use Your Gaming Laptop and Play On Battery Power? Is It Possible?
Of Opium, Spying, and Secret Silk Squares
Bayou Fever: Romare Bearden’s Dynamic Collages
Women at Work in the First World War
Best GPU deal: Get the MSI RTX 5080 for $1,249.99 at Best Buy
Watch Yourself: The Cows Are Out for Blood
Yevgeny Yevtushenko, “Olympic Champion of Poetry”
Reimagining Elena Ferrante’s “My Brilliant Friend” As a Building
25 TikTok, YouTube and Instagram creators who made it to TV, movies
What Is Poetry For?
NYT Connections hints and answers for January 20: Tips to solve 'Connections' #589.
Searching for Derek Walcott
What Does It Mean to Be Smart? Five Koans on Intelligence
Women Hold Up Half the Sky: Feminist Posters 1974–1990
Best AirPods deal: Apple AirPods 4 for $99.99 at Amazon
Hilton Als Wins Pultizer Prize for Criticism
Kiki Smith: “Portraits, Celestial Bodies, and Fairy Tales”
Getting Out Alive: Rethinking the End of “Goodbye, Columbus”
Cyrix: Gone But Not Forgotten
Mike Powell: Why I Live Where I Live
Sky Burial: How My First Date in Forty Years Ended in DisasterHollywood’s Ongoing Love Affair with Barf BagsLight of the World: Derek Walcott, 1930–2017Whitman Says: Quit Smirking and Eat Some Beef AlreadyRevisited: On Anselm Kiefer’s “Velimir Chlebnikov”White Nationalists Can’t Take Jane Austen Without a FightWhitman Says: Quit Smirking and Eat Some Beef AlreadyDream a Little Dream of Me: An Interview with Pénélope BagieuChances with Wolves and the Lonesome Labor of LivingWas Jane Austen Poisoned? Let’s Just Pretend…What Does It Mean to Be Smart? Five Koans on IntelligencePizza Complex Las Vegas: At the International Pizza ExpoHardware Store DoppelgängerRemembering Robert Silvers, 1929–2017Whiting Awards 2017: James Ijames, DramaAlice Neel and the Art of SelfWhiting Awards 2017: Simone White, PoetryPoolside with Chuck BerryHollywood’s Ongoing Love Affair with Barf BagsWhen Soviet Art Was Full of Hope Gmail search just got a lot smarter, thanks to AI 'Severance' Season 3 gets confirmed by Apple SpaceX's BFR has a new name. Elon Musk is calling it Starship. New panda mom doesn't know she has twins thanks to sneaky zookeepers Best smartwatch deal: Save 44% on CMF Watch Pro for $38.90 at Amazon Best smartwatch deal: Save $40 on the Fitbit Versa 4 Who is SpaceX's first moon passenger, Yusaku Maezawa? Scientists find supercolony of penguins on the remote Danger Islands Why Building a Gaming PC Right Now is a Bad Idea, Part 3: Bad Timing Amazon Big Spring Sale 2025: Best deals under $50 Amazon Spring Sale 2025: Best LG OLED TV deal We Test a $1,000 CPU From 2010 vs. Ryzen 3 Is 'Sing Sing' streaming? How to watch the A24 drama at home. How to Remotely Sign Out of Gmail on Multiple Devices Today's Hurdle hints and answers for April 7, 2025 Best grocery deal: Spend $20 and get $5 off at Amazon Why Building a Gaming PC Right Now is a Bad Idea, Part 2: Insane Graphics Card Prices LA Galaxy vs. Tigres 2025 livestream: Watch Concacaf Champions Cup for free Best robot vacuum deal: Get the Shark Matrix Plus 2 Researchers map the koala genome in the name of saving the species
3.5887s , 10139.0703125 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Naked Poison II】,Unobstructed Information Network